Equal Marriage Rights will need SCOTUS intervention

My congregation received a letter from the Unitarian Universalist Association last week officially recognizing us as a Welcoming Congregation.

Letter from the BGLT Concerns Office
Dear Pathways Church,

It is with great pleasure that I inform you that your congregation may be recognized officially as a Welcoming Congregation.

Our history shows that the liberal religious tradition is affirmed every time another congregation commits itself to being a human place that affirms, welcomes, and celebrates the presence of bisexual, gay, lesbian, and transgender persons. Though there remains a great deal of work to do in the Association before homophobia and transphobia become things of the past, it is congregations like yours that serve as an inspiration for those who have yet to begin the work of greater inclusion and understanding.

We are also sending you two posters, suitable for framing, that read “We are a Welcoming Congregation: This Unitarian Universalist community welcomes and celebrates the presence and participation of bisexual, gay, lesbian, and/or transgender people.”

Congratulations, and thanks! Sincerely,

Rev. Keith Kron, Directorog GLBT Concerns

This letter arrived during election week; during the week America elected its first black president and the week CA voted to actually take away rights from its gay citizens.  Our president-elect’s parents could not have been legally married in many states when he was born because interracial marriage was illegal at the time he was born in many states then.  It took a Supreme Court decision to change that.  That decision re-defined marriage.  I think it is going to take another Supreme Court decision to end this madness that treats some of our fellow citizens as lesser human beings. Fittingly, the election of the 44th president will most likely allow a court majority open-minded enough, sensible enough to understand that everyone is equal before the law or our claim as a nation that every person is created equal is meaningless.  I’m wondering if it will take mass action to get us there or if we are past that and what we need is the type of ground game that fueled the Obama campaign combined with the type of lobbying that made the equal marriage campaign successful in Massachusetts –   Peppering every state legislature in the country with constant citizen lobbying efforts of GLBT citizens and allies and every federal legislative office with the same. And then a test case in every state, so that the courts are overwhelmed. Eventually, one is going to have to be heard by the SCOTUS.

Racism rears its head in Texas after a black man is elected President

Strange but that blog post headline seems like it belongs in the 1950s, except for one thing.  The black man was running for office. Except the black man was running for President. Except for the fact that he WON.  Hate dies a slow, painful, tortured death as pain and agony are all it knows. Most people and most things die the way they live. Still it’s disturbing and I’m on edge waiting for the white hoods to make a final appearance before it’s all said and done. The news in the local morning paper just has me shaking my head today.

This is frightening, but it’s just the appetizer: In Fort Worth, Obama’s Election prompts run on guns and ammunition

Allan Craig is scared for the country and for himself.

So less than 48 hours after Democrat Barack Obama was elected president, Craig went out to buy an M-4 rifle.

“It’s for protection,” the 57-year-old funeral director from Weatherford said. “I’m fearful for our country. I think there will be violence. People want to go in and take over this country .?.?. trying to destroy America.

“I will protect myself and my family.”

I’m scared of people like this guy. Yes, there will be violence – from people who react to the election of our first black President buy running out to buy guns and bullets.  How do I protect my family from people like this?  Is there any protection from our neighbors who react to change and difference and diversity by arming themselves more heavily?  Tuesday night wasn’t the end, it was just the beginning. There is more work to do.

The main course was this: Area Schools deal with Racist Comments, Actions

Students at Colleyville Middle School used a social networking site to urge one another to wear black in protest of Obama’s victory, according to the parents of different students.

If it happened, campus administrators didn’t notice, Grapevine-Colleyville school district spokeswoman Megan Overman said. “There wasn’t anything organized, as far as we could tell,” she said.

There were hallway chants and untoward comments at a few Grapevine-Colleyville schools, including Colleyville Middle, since the election, but “those incidents have been handled,” Overman said.

The district has a character education program that focuses on civility, and the issues will also be discussed in some history classes, she said.

“We’re trying to turn this into learning opportunities,” Overman said. “Only every four years do we get a chance to talk about elections, and elections this historic are obviously much more rare.”

It seems like the character education program at this school isn’t very effective. Yes, Ms. Overman you only get to talk about elections every four years, but you get to do anti-racism/anti oppression education every day. If the Grapevine-Colleyville schools took these issues seriously and engaged them with students and parents would students get to middle school age and engage in this type of behavior? Possibly, you can’t stop everything, but a systemic anti racism education program that begins in the earliest years of schooling would leave middle schooler far less likely to engage in such behavior.

What we need now is reconciliation on a mass scale.  There are tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, perhaps even millions of people who are living in fear that in the aftermath of Tuesday’s election results there will be a mass revenge-taking, a mass table-turning.  I am getting the sense that racists feel like white South Africans after apartheid.  Perhaps our response needs to be as measured as was South Africa’s.  As justified as oppressed black South Africa might have been to turn the tables on their white oppressors at apartheid’s end, they did not.  They opted for the Truth and Reconciliation Commission instead.

There is a seismic shift going on among the political and social forces that have control of American public life for the last 28 years. Rev. Osagyefo Ushur Sekou writes, “Consider that for some years now one has been able to interchange the words ‘Christian’, ‘conservative’, ‘religious’, ‘right’, and ‘Republican’ in one sentence without necessarily changing the meaning of the sentence” (“Who’ God? Faith, Democracy and Making of an Authentic Religious Left” in Dispatches from the Religious Left pg. 64)  That dynamic is itself changing and came to a head Tuesday night. Those for whom this reality is a good thing are ready to move ahead into a new, more civil, more inclusive century.  Those for whom that old paradigm was a good thing are shaken to their bones. Some do not know how to handle it and are just plain scared, terrified.  From and out of that fear, they will act.  Hatred is making its stand against gay rights, racism is popping up in reaction to election results and what had been good manners have been lost as racist jokes become a way to identify as “us” against “them” in the new tolerant and welcoming world order.

Illinois Central

Good morning America, how are you?

Don’t you know me? I’m your native son.

It’s morning in America and the sky is blue.  A polarized nation placed it’s soul in the hands of black man from Illinois over the last two years and last night he delivered on the first part of the promise – that America could bridge the divides that once would have prevented his very election.

Part of the reason Barack Obama is the President-elect of the United States today is that he’s a preacher.  He understands both the practical and the pastoral need to bridge ideological divides, calling for an end to red states and blue states and recalling us to be United States.  His speeches such as the Yes We Can sequence, first debuted after the New Hampshire primary use a historical pride sequence, wrapped equally in our social justice and civil rights landmarks and our civil religion of founding fathers and military honors.  He has pulpit presence and it makes a difference.  Being called to be our best selves is not reserved for Sunday morning or Saturday or Friday. And in a nation where our leaders, even our President have been examples of our worst selves, lying and manipulating us into war, torturing enemies, spying, spreading attitudes of xenophobia and using fear as a weapon of social and political control, being called to a higher purpose resonated.  Barack Obama never had to say, “Americans are not liars, torturers, racists, bigots, spies,etc.”  He didn’t have to. Instead he reminded us what we are and we can do. It was a compelling call and many came to the altar, hoping against hope their fellow citizens would follow; hoping against hope that you, in your isolation weren’t the only one tired to the bone of a long national nightmare.

Every time it seemed the usual forces of fear and hate and cynicism would beat down Obama, he rose to the occasion and delivered yet another sermon.  (UPDATE - President-elect Obama’s prepared election eve remarks.)

2008 was the seventh time I’ve voted in a presidential election and he’s only the second winner I’ve ever voted for (Bill Clinton being the first).   I was so happy, I cried during his speech at Grant Park.  It was joy, but it was also relief.  Eight years of deceit, lies, spying, and eroding the freedoms and values upon which our country is founded are finally over.  Yet, it’s not the end, it’s just the beginning of solving the problems created by the worst presidential administration ever.

But this new President-Elect and his campaign have always been about hope. And hope is not an empty thing. It’s kept many of us going for going on eight years now.

Hope, as Andy told Red at Shawshank prison, “iis a good thing, maybe the best of things, and no good thing ever dies.”  And hope is not going away now. It will be a central theme for Obama going forward as he forges the coalition he needs to move his agenda.

Two little black girls will spend childhood in the White House comes a pundit voice from the TV behind me.  Finally, the America that never was but could be is finally starting to become real in astoundingly profound ways.  I’m so glad I’m on the train.

I will provide for you
And I’ll stand by your side
You’ll need a good companion for
This part of the ride
Leave behind your sorrows
Let this day be the last
Tomorrow there’ll be sunshine
And all this darkness past

Big wheels roll through fields
Where sunlight streams
Meet me in a land of hope and dreams

(unscientific) Proof Politics is a Sport

This election feels unlike any other in my lifetime.  I remember watching the returns of 1992 at the house of a friend whose dad was once governor of a certain mid-western swing state.  His dad was a “friend of Bill” and we’d get phone calls or my friend would make phone calls, it’s been a few years I can’t remember who phoned who, but we’d know if Clinton or Bush1 had won a state before the networks called them.  That was a unique experience.  It was the type of experience makes following an election like following your favorite sports team.

I’m from Massachusetts, one of those places in the country where it’s said politics is a sport.  Indeed, it feels like it this Texas morning to this Massachusetts politics geek and sports fan.  The last couple of times I had this kind of game-day anticipation the Patriots were in the Super Bowl against the Rams and the Red Sox were about to play game 4 of the World Series against the Cardinals in 2004.  Where will I be at game? Who will I watch it with? It’s all a bit ridiculous.  Except it’s not a game.  There’s no wait ’till next year if my team loses, the seasons are four years apart and I’ve endured two wait ’till next years in a row at the expense of dire consequences to the foundational values of our democracy such as habeas corpus, human rights, and fair elections (see Ohio 2004 and Florida 2000).  I’ve watched an administration try as hard as they can to turn a President into a king, use torture as a prefered policy, spy on our own citizens, and dig us a financial hole so deep we don’t yet what it’s gonna take to dig out.  People who disagree with the administration’s politics have been cast unpatriotic, not as the loyal opposition.  It’s game time and I want my country back.

Here are some good guide to watching the election results come in from Nate Silver of fivethirtyeight.com in a piece for Newsweek and Katharine Q. Seelye of the New York Times. Kula 2316 has a great diary up at dailyKos about what to look for tonight with a nice graphic from the SwingStateProject (on poll closing times).  All of them agree that if Obama’s going to have good night, we’re going to know early, as some of the big scores such Indiana, Virginia, Florida, and Georgia close their polls earliest in the country and if Obama is winning some of them, McCain’s road map to 270 electoral votes gets slimmer. If Obama is winning all of them, warm up the Opera singer’s vocal chords and get the fork ready and the broom out.

But then again, that’s why they play the game.  You can’t just mail in your press clippings. Teams may look good on paper, but once they get on the field. On any given Tuesday…USA 4, Russia 3, etc.  So get out and vote.

The Waiting is the Hardest Part

There’s not much to do now, but Get Out the Vote and wait.  That’s the hardest part.  Dixville Notch, NH, the tiny village in NH that votes first in the country has voted for Obama, and by more than a 2-1 margin. This resulet is, I hope, a harbinger of things to come,  as Dixville Notch has voted for Bush 1 (twice), Dole and Bush 2 (twice).

I don’t think Tom Petty was writing about elections, when penned this tune, but it does speak to the mood Obama supporters are in as election day dawns in 2008.

The Waiting by Tom Petty

Oh baby don’t it feel like heaven right now
Don’t it feel like somethin’ from a dream
Yeah I’ve never known nothing quite like this
Don’t it feel like tonight might never be again
We know better than to try and pretend
Baby no one could have ever told me bout this

The waiting is the hardest part
Every day you see one more card
You take it on faith, you take it to the heart
The waiting is the hardest part

Well yeah I might have chased a couple of women (candidates!) around
All it ever got me was down
Then there were those that made me feel good
But never as good as I feel right now
Baby you’re the only one that’s ever known how
To make me wanna live like I wanna live now

The waiting is the hardest part
Every day you see one more card
You take it on faith, you take it to the heart
The waiting is the hardest part

Don’t let it kill you baby, don’t let it get to you
Don’t let em kill you baby, don’t let em get to you
I’ll be your breathin’ heart, I’ll be your cryin fool
Don’t let this go to far, don’t let it get to you

The Boss sings for labor

Thanks once again to my friends Eric at Life is a Mystery and Mary at Tensegrities for making me aware of a video showing the Boss preaching for the hope of the future.Here you have the most highly paid theologian in America, Bruce Springsteen, singing as he does so well about those aren’t so well paid.  The Boss certainly makes well over $250,000 a year and will be paying substainially more income taxes come the dawn of an Obama presidency, and yet here he is in Cleveland, OH singing his song Youngstown, about the folks who work the mills there and make substaintially less than $250,000 a year.

The Boss singing about Youngstown, Ohio from Rick Pollack on Vimeo.

The rich only taking care of the rich doesn’t work.  Joe the Steel Worker is going to be much better off backing Obama:

Seven-hundred tons of metal a day
Now sir you tell me the world’s changed
Once I made you rich enough
Rich enough to forget my name.

Because this is the world that trickle down and deregulation have brought us.  A world run by those who parade an arch religious conservative as a Vice Presidential candidate but who as the Biblical prophet Amos says, “sell the righteous for silver, and the needy for a pair of sandals,  who trample the head of the poor into the dust of the earth, and push the afflicted out of the way.”

Here’s the complete lyric:

Here in north east Ohio
Back in eighteen-o-three
James and Danny Heaton
Found the ore that was linin’ yellow creek
They built a blast furnace
Here along the shore
And they made the cannon balls
That helped the union win the war

Here in Youngstown
Here in Youngstown
My sweet Jenny, I’m sinkin’ down
Here darlin’ in Youngstown

Well my daddy worked the furnaces
Kept ‘em hotter than hell
I come home from ‘Nam worked my way to scarfer
A job that’d suit the devil as well
Taconite, coke and limestone
Fed my children and made my pay
Then smokestacks reachin’ like the arms of god
Into a beautiful sky of soot and clay

Here in Youngstown
Here in Youngstown
My sweet Jenny, I’m sinkin’ down
Here darlin’ in Youngstown

Well my daddy come on the 0hio works
When he come home from world war two
Now the yards just scrap and rubble
He said, “Them big boys did what Hitler couldn’t do”
These mills they built the tanks and bombs
That won this country’s wars
We sent our sons to Korea and Vietnam
Now we’re wondering what they were dyin’ for

Here in Youngstown
Here in Youngstown
My sweet Jenny, I’m sinkin’ down
Here darlin’ in Youngstown

From the Monongaleh valley
To the Mesabi iron range
To the coal mines of Appalacchia
The story’s always the same
Seven-hundred tons of metal a day
Now sir you tell me the world’s changed
Once I made you rich enough
Rich enough to forget my name

In Youngstown
In Youngstown
My sweet Jenny, I’m sinkin’ down
Here darlin’ in Youngstown

When I die I don’t want no part of heaven
I would not do heavens work well
I pray the devil comes and takes me
To stand in the fiery furnaces of hell

Even in a redrawn electoral map, I'm (sort of) disenfranchised – updated

I’ve moved from Massachusetts to Texas in the last few months and nothing’s changed as far as my vote is concerned.  My home has changed, but this year as in 2004 and 2000, my home state still hasn’t gotten so much as a sniff of Presidential campaign appearance.  That’s because when I lived in Massachusetts, the Bay State’s electoral college’s votes were a lock for the Democratic Party’s candidate and now that I live in Texas, the Lone Star State’s electoral votes are a lock for the Republican Party’s candidate.  When I lived in Massachusetts, I tended to vote Green anyway, in an effort to build not a third party, but a viable SECOND party in what amounts to one-party Democratically run Massachusetts.  The need for such has been brought home by the ethics scandals rocking the democratically controlled state house there this fall.

Now, here I am in Texas, having switched my voter registration to unenrolled back in January in MA again here in Texas in August to support Barack Obama, for reasons that are as much pastoral as political (my freind Eric points to as good an explanation as I can offer here).  And yet the overwhelming vote here in Texas is probably, although I hope not, going to be for McCain.

dailyKos today points to an informative, although by no means revolutionary post from Nate Silver at 538.com that reminds us that this election, like every other Presidential election is really 50 elections because of the electoral college.  And this year it comes down to this:

This is beginning to look like a five-state election. Those states are Virginia, Colorado, Pennsylvania, Ohio and Nevada. Essentially all relevant electoral scenarios involve some combination of these five states…

The victory conditions for Obama involving these five states proceed something as follows:

  1. Win Pennsylvania and ANY ONE of Colorado, Virginia, Ohio, or Nevada*
  1. Win Ohio and EITHER Colorado OR Virginia.
  1. Win Colorado AND Virginia AND Nevada.

(* Nevada produces a 269-269 tie, which would probably be resolved for Obama in the House of Represenatives.)

Now, suppose you think that Colorado is already in the bag for Obama because of his large edge in early voting there. We can then simplify the victory conditions as follows:

  1. Win Pennsylvania
  1. Win Ohio
  • Win Virginia AND Nevada
  • This graphic from Pollster.com (again a hat tip to dailyKos) puts the race in a linear perspective, sort of an slide rule. Obama needs to grab a light blue state and McCain all the yellow toss up swing states and a bunch of light blue Obama leaning light blue states.

    It’s really time to do away with the electoral college once and for all.  In spite of Obama’s efforts to make this a 50 state campaign, he’s doing it out of electoral strategy and a mandate to govern, not out an electoral philosphy that argues the POUS should be popularly elected by the people.  Popular election of the President requires a constitutional amendment. I stand corrected (see the comments) One way around it is a state law that pledges all the states electoral votes to the popular vote winner. See National Popular Vote for more information on their plan.  I’d still rather have a Constitutional amendment (such as the one that supplied popular direct election of senators), but I’d settle for their plan in the interim.

    UPDATE – In the Nov. 2 edition of the New York Times, Sarah K. Cowan points out that:

    This system (the electoral college), along with the winner-take-all practice used to allocate most states’ electoral votes, creates the potential for an absurd outcome. In the unlikely event that all 213 million eligible voters cast ballots, either John McCain or Barack Obama could win enough states to capture the White House with only 47.8 million strategically located votes. The presidency could be won with just 22 percent of the electorate’s support, only 16 percent of the entire population’s.

    With direct election you get the President the most people want.  I also want Rank choice voting, also called Instant Run Off Voting (let the muppets explain it to you) so I can vote for my actual policy preferences without the fear of putting my least favorite candidate like Bush or McCain in the White House.

    Until then candidate have to have an electoral strategy and I have to have a voting strategy and that’s not what democracy should  look like.